On Joy and Yom Kippur
(This sermon is protected by a Creative Commons license. Please link and attribute.)
For most of my life, I thought of Yom Kippur as a time that was serious, bordering on the dour. Itâ€™s a time for fear and trembling, a time for deep, powerful, intense work, and of course fasting and other forms of self-affliction. And all of that is true, but there was another side of the day that I didnâ€™t understand until my first Yom Kippur in Jerusalem, when I was in rabbinical school.
Then, I found myself at a lay-led congregation known for its passionate singing and tremendous energy. The services wereâ€¦ joyful. At the end, towards Neilah, the most fervent moment in the day, right as the gates of Heaven are poised to closeâ€”at the Leader minyan, we danced. Danced! We shook our butts lâ€™shem shamayim, for the sake of heaven, we laughed and sang and then we danced some more as we asked for our lives to be rendered anew. That the Day of Atonement could be joyful? Had simply never occurred to me.
Judaismâ€™s great minds knew already, though. The Talmud tells us, straight up: â€œAtonement and joy go well together.â€ The medieval Kabbalistic book the Zohar makes the same case, but even stronger: â€œYom Ha-Kippurim, hu yom kâ€™Purim.â€ Yom Kippur is a day like Purim– the silly, irreverent carnival dedicated to joy and playfulness. Today is considered to be an ideal day for romantic matchmaking, and the rituals of Yom Kippurâ€”fasting, ritually confessing, wearing whiteâ€”are mirrored intentionally in the Jewish wedding ceremony.
None of this seems obvious, does it? But then again, joy isnâ€™t obvious.
When weâ€™re feeling most things, most times, thereâ€™s an element of distraction to it. Weâ€™re sad about now and afraid about the future, weâ€™re angry about something that just happened because it taps into a whole host of things that happened a long time ago. We are so often bound up into a whole, complex network of thoughts and ideas from the past and the future. We manage, sometimes, to be both in the moment and somewhere else, in another point along the spectrum of timeâ€”torn, ever-so-slightly, in two or more pieces.
When weâ€™re feeling joy, on the other hand, thereâ€™s only the moment of joy, and we take it in fully. We tend to experience more, and are newly attuned to the small, everyday flashes of beauty and grace that populate our lives. We suddenly notice the loveliness of the flowers on the side of the road, the crisp sweetness of an apple, the kindness paid to us by someone we encounter briefly. In joy, we feel more sensitized, more awake, more alive. And itâ€™s that sensitivity, that openness, that situating oneself entirely in the present moment that opens us also to the transcendent, the holy, to the sacred stream of life that flows through us, connects us, surrounds us.
And yet, as Rebbe Nachman of Breslov has said, â€œFinding true joy is the hardest of all spiritual tasks.â€
Joy is actually hard and threatening for many of us, difficult to tolerate. We know how to do hurt, resentful, afraid, angryâ€”those are familiar states, with a perverse sort of comfort to them. They may not be pleasant, but we know them, know how they work, know who we are with them. Joy? Joy is the unknown. We donâ€™t always feel like we know who we are in the unfettered openness of the present moment, what might give shape to our lives if not the recurring drama, the clinging to the past or the crafting of stories about some vague, hypothetical future. Being present in the moment means accepting what isâ€”not rewriting what happened, not desperately crafting what happens next. Itâ€™s hard to be happy. It touches a place deeper and more primal than even all of the old feelings of self-annihilation, something much closer to the core of who we really are. And that? Thatâ€™s terrifying.
Feeling happy makes us vulnerable in a way that feeling terrible doesnâ€™t. Because there is, suddenly, something to lose. Various Jewish cultures around the world have tapped into that, externalizing and personifying our fears about the fact that joy is non-permanent. My mother would always tell me not to talk about how well things were going, because the dybbuksâ€”the demonsâ€”were listening, and would surely throw a wrench in my plans, or that Iâ€™d give myself a kenahorah, entanglement with the evil eye. Or, if you do admit your happiness, you have to negate it–again, as protection against the evil eye: â€œThings are going really well, puh puh puh.â€ Itâ€™s almost comical, except for the ways in which it reveals the abject terror we all have to just sitting with the joy we have, to owning it, to acknowledging it. Maybe we feel like thereâ€™ll have to be some price to pay later on for all the magic weâ€™re experiencing now. Maybe we just donâ€™t trust that this happiness is really here, is really real. Or maybe itâ€™s something else, as Marianne Williamson suggests, in a famous, but important passage. She writes,
Our deepest fear is not that we are inadequate. Our deepest fear is that we are powerful beyond measure. It is our light, not our darkness, that most frightens us. We ask ourselves, â€œwho am I to be brilliant, gorgeous, talented and fabulous?â€ Actually, who are you not to be? You are a child of God. Your playing small doesn’t serve the world. There’s nothing enlightened about shrinking so that other people won’t feel insecure around you. We were born to make and manifest the glory of God that is within us. It’s not just in some of us; it’s in everyone. And as we let our own light shine, we unconsciously give other people permission to do the same. As we are liberated from our own fear, our presence automatically liberates others.
Yom Kippur is the day when we taste a measure of our own power, our own light, our own expansive greatness. The day itself washes us clean. All the old hurts and angers can be, if we let them, released into the great beyond. Today we go deep down into the core of our being and excavate everything that doesnâ€™t belong, we offer up our indiscretions, our pettiness, our smallness, our fear and our angerâ€”taking it out of our hearts, naming it, and telling it that it doesnâ€™t need to rule over us any more.
Part of how we get there is by letting the hard stuff in. Sometimes the present moment is painful, and we need to stay present until the pain ebbs away. We can let go of the hurt and anger and sadness by first giving ourselves space to feel them, fullyâ€”trusting that they won’t destroy us, that given enough room to have full reign, after a while all the hard feelings will eventually wander off somewhere else.
And part of how we get there is by letting go. We need to let go of old narratives of ourselves and our hurts and sadnesses, and we need to make space for the magic and the mystery of right now. And when joy comes, when you let it in, you have a choice. You can try to bind yourself to it, get yourself tangled up in, it so that when you meet someone new, you’re already thinking and wondering if he or she will be someone you want to have around in your life on a permanent basis. You can decide that loving one class means that you must spend the rest of your life on that subject. You can become attached to the story turning out one particular way and inevitably be disappointed when it unfolds in a different direction. Or you can kiss the joy as it flies, as William Blake put it, and relish the moment of a wonderful conversation, a wonderful evening, a wonderful classâ€”and wait with eager curiosity to see what might happen next. If your self is whole and not torn, it becomes impossible to do anything but let the moments flow through you, the joy flow through you. And this day, all of it, is meant to help you get there.
Rituals of purification are meant to lift us higher and higher into joy. Fasting is means for altering consciousness and helping us to access a state thatâ€™s difficult when we are full and grounded. Abstaining from leather lowers our defenses as we take down protective armor. And most importantly, naming all the ways our lives have been dysfunctional, all the ways weâ€™ve strayed from who we should be, open a door wide for new possibilities.
The past has already been broken. The future is ultimately out of our hands. All we have, in this moment, is this present moment, the now of our time here in contemplation, introspection, and meditation, the now of our connection to our selves and all of our great, glimmering potential, of all of the light straining to get out.
Today is the day both of last chances and of ultimate opportunities. “Who shall live and who shall die…?”, the liturgy asks. Today is the day we must live, and live better than we ever have. Today is the day we must seize our lives, take hold of them, to become wider and bigger and fuller than we’ve ever been. To radiate out, in all directionsâ€”to not hide, to know that this is our moment for joy, this is our moment for becoming as powerful as we already are. So take the joy now, with both hands, greedily, and through it allow yourself to be made new, in this present moment, and to shine on with your great, gorgeous light.